Eddie B 1:28 Wed Jan 14
Refereeing question about tonight
|
|
Their goalkeeper had already been booked and was play acting like a cunt during the penalties. The ref thought about booking him, got his card out to do so, realised he'd already got a yellow, so promptly shit himself and didn't.
What would've happened if he'd shown him a 2nd yellow, would they have had to put an outfield player in goal?
|
|
|
Replies - Newest Posts First ( Show In Chronological Order)
DukeofDevo
12:31 Thu Jan 15
Re: Refereeing question about tonight
|
Officially the worst season for refing cock ups, and we've been on the end of some game changers!
|
Sniper
12:27 Thu Jan 15
Re: Refereeing question about tonight
|
He's not half as much if a bottler as the ref in the league game at goodison. They should have been down to about 8 players!
|
DukeofDevo
12:25 Thu Jan 15
Re: Refereeing question about tonight
|
I thought the red was doing ok for most of it but then he misses a clear penalty for us and gives them a silly free kick when Morrellas dives into Tomkins for a non foul!
Morrellas could have easily picked up 2 yellows as well
|
Ronald_antly
12:19 Thu Jan 15
Re: Refereeing question about tonight
|
It's a good job James Collins wasn't eligible to take a kick.
He'd probably have stood the wrong side of the ball and hoofed it upfield expecting Carroll to get on the end of it.
|
Jasnik
6:16 Wed Jan 14
Re: Refereeing question about tonight
|
Thanks ..
|
Jasnik
6:15 Wed Jan 14
Re: Refereeing question about tonight
|
Than Iron Duke.
Well if he gave their keeper a card he probably would have had to have booked Adrian when he spoke to Jagielka .
Seemed to make him miss.
|
WHOicidal Maniac
6:13 Wed Jan 14
Re: Refereeing question about tonight
|
So the ref bottled it and didnt show him the card. Doesnt matter now but what if Everton had won?
A red card bans the player from the next match right ? Everton already in the shit with their regular No.1 keeper being out...that could of had serious implications in the match should Everton have met Bristol.
Saying that, that was just one decision that the ref bottled in an entire evening of bottling decisions...
|
Iron Duke
6:13 Wed Jan 14
Re: Refereeing question about tonight
|
I think Adrian had stepped into the penalty area.
|
Jasnik
6:12 Wed Jan 14
Re: Refereeing question about tonight
|
I have one question what was the Ref doing when Cresswell went to take his kick ?
|
SurfaceAgentX2Zero
6:05 Wed Jan 14
Re: Refereeing question about tonight
|
Dom 3:13 Wed Jan 14
I didn't see that, mate, but I won't dispute it if that's what you saw.
He was still a weak cunt, though!
|
Dom
4:06 Wed Jan 14
Re: Refereeing question about tonight
|
Iron Duke 3:59 Wed Jan 14
we could nominate any of our 11 players not to take
|
Iron Duke
3:59 Wed Jan 14
Re: Refereeing question about tonight
|
So did we have to nominate an outfield player not to take a penalty, ie Tomkins?
I'm glad we did, obviously.
|
The Joker
3:57 Wed Jan 14
Re: Refereeing question about tonight
|
Ricky M 3:24 Wed Jan 14
i.e. A substitute keeper cannot be brought on, as would normally happen (assuming the side has subs left).
|
FOMB
3:53 Wed Jan 14
Re: Refereeing question about tonight
|
I added a bit more detail though :-)
|
FOMB
3:52 Wed Jan 14
Re: Refereeing question about tonight
|
In that instance he was replaced in goal by one of the defenders
|
Trevor B
3:51 Wed Jan 14
Re: Refereeing question about tonight
|
mentioned that earlier
|
FOMB
3:51 Wed Jan 14
Re: Refereeing question about tonight
|
A goalkeeper HAS been sent off during a penalty shoot out before
A game between Botswana and Malawi went to penalties and during the shoot out the Mawali keeper patted the Botswana keeper on the back and he responded by punching him in the face!
|
Ricky M
3:24 Wed Jan 14
Re: Refereeing question about tonight
|
I looked this up.....
"If the goalkeeper is sent off during the taking of kicks from the penalty mark, he shall be replaced by a player who finished the match"
|
claretandbluedagger
3:15 Wed Jan 14
Re: Refereeing question about tonight
|
In fairness, with regards to choosing someone not to take part if the other team has had a player sent off, it can make sense. Imagine if Adrian had missed the pen, and Tomkins had to take the next one. That would've meant the 11th penalties would be Tomkins vs their best penalty taker - not ideal for us!
|
Dom
3:13 Wed Jan 14
Re: Refereeing question about tonight
|
SurfaceAgentX2Zero 10:37 Wed Jan 14
didnt he have them out every time as he was checking the takers names and marking whether they scored ?
im sure he had it out a couple of times when adrian was in goal as well
|
Dom
3:12 Wed Jan 14
Re: Refereeing question about tonight
|
Robson 3:02 Wed Jan 14
ditto
|
| 
